Linda Holmes, NPR, regarding I Feel Pretty:
For some women, two lessons exist in constant tension: (1) You must be pretty to be valued, but (2) It’s really what’s on the inside that counts. This can — or so I may have hypothetically heard — set off a repeating loop that goes something like this:
I am not happy with my looks. —> I am not good. —> It’s really what’s on the inside that counts. —> This means my insides are not good either, or I would be good. And I am not good, because —> I am not happy with my looks.
Holmes sets up the plot of the not so prettily reviewed comedy I Feel Pretty, starring Amy Schumer:
…I Feel Pretty, written and directed by Abby Kohn and Marc Silverstein, is aptly named; it’s not about what it’s like to be pretty as much as what it’s like to feel pretty. It’s about the mythical power some women attach to being beautiful in those specific ways most commonly associated with social power: thin, smooth and unblemished skin, the ‘right’ bone structure, the ‘right’ kind of chin and nose and wide eyes, the thick and healthy hair of a shampoo model.
The key turning point explained by Moira Macdonald, Seattle Times:
Renee [Schumer], inspired by a viewing of ‘Big,’ wishes to be beautiful — and one day, after suffering a head injury at Soul Cycle, she wakes up believing it’s true. She looks exactly the same to the world — and to us — but she now sees herself to be stunning, and throws herself into her life with a new self-confidence, quickly acquiring a glamorous new job and a nice new boyfriend (Rory Scovel).
Sheri Linden, Hollywood Reporter: “But feeling beautiful also makes her condescending, presumptuous, vain and snobby.”
Anne Cohen, Refinery29: “Renee’s experience is definitely that of a white, privileged woman who has the time and resources to worry about how she looks on a minute level. The lack of diversity in the film makes it far less inclusive than it should be…”
Another common complaint: the lack of depth to the non-Renee characterizations. Sara Stewart, New York Post:
Michelle Williams shows up as another blonde with confidence problems: The granddaughter of the company’s founder, she’s got an unfortunately squeaky voice. Aidy Bryant and an oddly tan Busy Philipps play Schumer’s best friends, apparently a couple of 5s at best; we know this because they favor cardigans and pants. Model Emily Ratajkowski plays . . . a beautiful woman. Only Rory Scovel, as Renee’s adoring and Zumba-loving new boyfriend Ethan, comes off as a real, quirky person instead of a retro caricature. Kudos to him, but for a movie that’s purportedly about female empowerment, it’s not a great look.
An important point, however: “To the movie’s credit, it doesn’t pit women against each other but rather has them build one another up” (Aisha Harris, Slate).
Watch the trailer, then read on for further reflections:
Anne Cohen, Refinery 29: “…It’s that inability to ever feel true satisfaction with oneself, to always strive for more attractive, more glamorous, more stylish, that I Feel Pretty seeks to make light of. And there, it does succeed.”
Inkoo Kang, The Wrap: “The movie that ‘I Feel Pretty’ should have been deserves to be made. This version, in which a narcissist learns to love herself as is, feels far less necessary.”
Mara Weinstein, Us Weekly: “…(I)t sticks to basic lessons, such as the revelation that beautiful women have boyfriend problems too!!”
Alissa Wilkinson, Vox: “There’s a potentially funny movie in here somewhere. But it lumbers along, wasting some of its greatest assets and, in the end, overstaying its welcome.”
Katie Walsh, Tribune News Service: “Renee works at a beauty company, but we never stop to examine into the industry’s practices of keeping women feeling bad so they continue spending money trying to feel pretty.”